Starting results calculation at Sun Dec 28 00:03:02 2008 Option 1 "Reaffirm the Social Contract" Option 2 "Allow Lenny to release with proprietary firmware [3:1]" Option 3 "Allow Lenny to release with DFSG violations [3:1]" Option 4 "Empower the release team to decide about allowing DFSG violations [3:1]" Option 5 "Assume blobs comply with GPL unless proven otherwise" Option 6 "Exclude source requirements for firmware (defined) [3:1]" Option 7 "Further Discussion" In the following table, tally[row x][col y] represents the votes that option x received over option y. Option 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 === === === === === === === Option 1 46 60 72 73 89 117 Option 2 281 160 160 171 177 224 Option 3 255 61 125 137 151 204 Option 4 253 121 146 160 166 194 Option 5 234 105 128 135 136 191 Option 6 220 118 134 125 134 180 Option 7 226 129 145 153 160 169 Looking at row 2, column 1, Allow Lenny to release with proprietary firmware [3:1] received 281 votes over Reaffirm the Social Contract Looking at row 1, column 2, Reaffirm the Social Contract received 46 votes over Allow Lenny to release with proprietary firmware [3:1]. Option 1 Reached quorum: 117 > 47.8591684006314 Option 2 Reached quorum: 224 > 47.8591684006314 Option 3 Reached quorum: 204 > 47.8591684006314 Option 4 Reached quorum: 194 > 47.8591684006314 Option 5 Reached quorum: 191 > 47.8591684006314 Option 6 Reached quorum: 180 > 47.8591684006314 Dropping Option 1 because of Majority. (0.5176991150442477876106194690265486725664) 0.518 (117/226) < 1 Dropping Option 2 because of Majority. (1.736434108527131782945736434108527131783) 1.736 (224/129) < 3 Dropping Option 3 because of Majority. (1.406896551724137931034482758620689655172) 1.407 (204/145) < 3 Dropping Option 4 because of Majority. (1.267973856209150326797385620915032679739) 1.268 (194/153) < 3 Option 5 passes Majority. 1.194 (191/160) >= 1 Dropping Option 6 because of Majority. (1.065088757396449704142011834319526627219) 1.065 (180/169) < 3 Option 5 defeats Option 7 by ( 191 - 160) = 31 votes. The Schwartz Set contains: Option 5 "Assume blobs comply with GPL unless proven otherwise" -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= The winners are: Option 5 "Assume blobs comply with GPL unless proven otherwise" -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=